Qualifiers
by Miriam Hlavaty. Published September 20th, 2022.
In order to judge the outcome of a practice session, most of us tend to have a set of qualifiers -things which we take as a sign that we have either succeeded or failed in what we are doing. But the type of qualifiers we use are closely linked to how efficient we are. And how well our body functions during playing.
In the life of a musician, a lot of time is spent alone in rehearsal rooms, practicing new repertoire or refining and building technical excellence. It is a time and a situation when we become intimately acquainted with our own inner climate, most often manifesting as an instant personal feedback based on how well we are performing.
Without the ability to assess our performance, any type of rehearsal would be more or less impossible. A rehearsal is a constant loop of trying, assessing, and re-trying. But the way we assess our performance can differ. It can also often be the magic ingredient which increases the output of your practice session dramatically.
So how do we make an assessment of an activity? Very often by looking for some kind of marker as to how well we are doing. We could call these markers for qualifiers.
Just take a moment and consider for yourself: What do you use as a qualifier to judge how well your rehearsal session went?
how many hours you have practiced?
how fast you are able to play certain passages at the end?
the degree of pain or discomfort afterwards in your arms, shoulders and neck or just your body in general?
how you feel afterwards?
A qualifier might be concrete and measurable or more vague. Here is an example of concrete qualifiers which are a useful part of a practice routine:
being able to play certain parts of the music by heart
being able to play that difficult passage on page x at a certain speed
being able to fully master that specific rhytmic pattern on page x.
These qualifiers give us a concrete way of measuring the outcome of our practice session and, thereby, our degree of «efficiency». They also might make it easier to know how to progress with a problem:
I was able to play that piece of music by heart.
I was able to play that difficult passage almost at the speed I´m going for and I discovered that I need to memorize passages x, y, and z better in order to get the speed up to where I want it to be.
I still have some issues with the rhythmical pattern and need to ask a teacher for input on how to solve it.
I should be feeling…
But sometimes our qualifiers might be more unconcious and abstract, more like an unspoken rule which we might not be fully aware of, but which a part of us nevertheless hold as a truth.
I might for instance have an unconscious expectation that a «good» practice session will make me feel a certain way. And my subconscious might be expecting this particular feeling as a qualifier that I have succeded or, by the lack of it, that the practice session has been a total waste of time.
Qualifiers are important because they are a way for our subconscious to judge ourselves and our actions, not to mention a way for us to judge the actions of others.
They might also easily be confused with our «gut feeling».
Here are some relatively common abstract «qualifiers» in the music world which might be more or less conscious:
True art is serious and demands hard work and often suffering, physically or mentally. If I´m too happy and things feel too easy, it means I´m missing something.
Only people who practice more than x hours a day have a chance at becoming really good. Me practicing for less than x hours and feeling happy means I´m not applying myself fully and that the session was a failure.
Being a successful musician means you do not get stage fright, so feeling fear or anxiety means I´m doing something wrong.
In order to express passionate music, I need to be able to feel the passion myself as I´m playing. If I´m not feeling it, it means I´m faking it/not being genuine.
A good concert experience or practice session should always leave you feeling elated and happy. If I feel anything else it means the concert/practice session did not go well.
Notice how all of these qualifiers are based on how something feels?
The trouble with qualifiers which are based on how something should feel is that they ignore the fact that change, including the physiological changes that happen in the brain and body during learning something new, very often trigger feelings of discomfort, no matter how useful and necessary the change.
In order to re-train or learn a new movement pattern when playing our brain needs to change, and the brain is by default in an energy preservation mode. Doing something which demands an increase of energy can often trigger a sense of unease. If we then take this sensation as a qualifier that we have not been efficient because we are not feeling elated or radiantly happy, we are misinterpreting the signs our body is sending us.
The sensation is not a sign that we are not being effective, it is simply a sign that we are doing something new, - also known as learning.
Another reason why it might be good not to always use emotional sensations as Qualifiers has to do with a part of our nervous system called interoception. Just as our exteroception is based on sensory input from our surroundings and our external world, our interoception is about the brain’s ability to detect signals from our internal world: activity in our organs, how much food we have in our stomach, the resting tension in our muscles and connective tissue. Interoceptive signals goes to a part of the brain called the insula, and this part of the brain is, among other things, concerned with our somatic experiencing, - in other words: how the movements we do with our bodies is linked to how we feel.
Inner somatic sensations have a huge influence on our lives, more than most of us realize, because very often the way something makes us feel is a decisive factor in if we choose to do it or not.
In other words: Our physical sensations play a big role as a motivational or discouraging factor.
In some situations, this is a good thing: when something smells rotten or tastes bad, our first instinct is, rightfully, to back away or spit it out.
But in another situation, the somatic discomfort might simply arise because we are trying to change an old movement pattern.
As a pianist, I spent 10 years playing with massive tension in my shoulder area. The tension allowed my body to have the stability it needed in order to play but at the price of developing tendinitis (yes, «tension» is actually necessary in order to play, but more of that in a later article).
Understanding how to relocate the “tension” to parts of the body that were more capable of long-term support while playing was a long process. This process did not always feel good as it involved releasing tension from parts which were used to acting as solid parts. Tension is also a thing our body uses to protect us within experiences which are unpleasant or overwhelming. Releasing tension can, therefore easily trigger emotional reactions of different kinds.
Last but not least: the way we treat ourselves after we have judged our performance less than desirable plays a much bigger role in our performance than most people think. That inner climate which we bring into our practice room has a direct physiological effect on how well your body is able to perform technically.
As grown-ups, we have the sole responsibility of how we talk to ourselves when alone and what language we use. Have you ever been scolded by someone for something?
When under attack, certain physiological mechanisms and hormonal changes are set in motion, which has a direct effect on the muscles of the body.
And your brain can´t tell the difference if the scolding is coming from someone else or from yourself.
So take note next time you are in the practice room. What qualifiers are you using? And is the language you use towards yourself the same you would use towards a friend?
BIO
Miriam M. M. Hlavatý is a Timani master teacher, pianist, bodyworker, somatic coach and lecturer who lives in Oslo, Norway. She is trained as a classical pianist at the Norwegian Academy of Music and as a certified Timani teacher at the Musicians Health and Movement Institute in Oslo where she now works as an institute teacher. She holds annual lectures on Timani, Pain, the Nervous system and the Fascia system at the Musicians Health and Movement Institute in Oslo and at the Institute of Music at NTNU, Trondheim. She has given courses and lectures both in Norway and abroad. She runs the company The Listening Experience, dedicated to the exploration of the many cross sections between body, mind and music.